You read that right, in my fist real blogpost since 2014 I decided to give credits to the manosphere.
An appreciation of male self-improvement, a few biological observations and a small request for mutual respect.
Let’s start with something controversial: I actually think the manosphere has some good things going for it. Yes, you read that correctly.
Men encouraging other men to exercise regularly, eat healthily, take care of their appearance, find a job, build a career, become financially independent and learn how to provide for a family? Excellent! Absolutely wonderful. More of that, please. A healthy body is a happy body. Knowing how to dress appropriately, maintain personal hygiene, manage your finances and take responsibility for your life are useful skills. Skills that tend to come in rather handy when you’re an adult. Learning how to climb the career ladder, start a business or lead a company? Also useful.
And if you need a course, a podcast, a YouTube video or a list of instructions to get there, by all means, go ahead. There is absolutely nothing wrong with learning from other people. In fact, I’m rather impressed.
Apparently, some men have discovered the revolutionary concept of eating vegetables, exercising and washing themselves regularly. Congratulations, gentlemen! We are all very proud.
The business of becoming a man
The manosphere has created an entire industry around teaching men how to become successful, wealthy, attractive and independent. There are courses, programmes, coaching sessions and influencers explaining how to dress, behave, communicate, invest, date, lead and live. And honestly, I have some appreciation for the men who create these courses.
It takes a certain amount of confidence to put yourself out there, share your knowledge and help other people improve their lives. It also takes a willingness to acknowledge that other men might need some guidance, and so did you before all this.
However, I do wonder whether anyone has considered where some of these men learned their most fundamental life skills in the first place. From their mothers? Their grandmothers? Female teachers? Older sisters? You know, those people who taught them how to eat properly, brush their teeth, wash their clothes, behave around other people and generally function in society? The people who kept repeating this over and over again?
Perhaps a little appreciation is in order.
A small biological reminder
Since we’re discussing superiority, leadership and the importance of men, let’s take a little trip back to biology.
Every man reading this started his existence inside a woman’s body. Men contribute sperm to reproduction, of course. But pregnancy and childbirth require a gestational parent. And the biological father isn’t necessarily present during pregnancy, childbirth or the subsequent years of raising a child.
Women have been bringing new generations into the world, often raising them with little or no support from the biological father. And before someone starts explaining how men are the providers and protectors, let me remind you that providing and protecting are actions, not personality traits. You don’t become a provider by announcing that you’re one. You don’t become a protector by wearing a particular watch, driving an expensive car or listening to a podcast about alpha males.
And you certainly don’t become a good father by promising your future wife that you’ll be one. Words don’t pay bills. Words don’t put food on the table. Words don’t raise children. Actions do!
Monkey see, monkey do
This is perhaps the most fascinating part of the manosphere. Men are encouraged to become independent thinkers, strong leaders and dominant individuals. Yet many seem perfectly happy to copy another man’s opinions, vocabulary, lifestyle, relationship advice and definition of success. Monkey see, monkey do.
They idolise a man, repeat what he says, adopt his promises and aspire to become his exact replica. They want what he wants, say what he says and do what he does. And somehow, this is presented as independence.
There is nothing wrong with having role models. We all learn by observing others. That’s a fundamental part of human social learning. But perhaps we should distinguish between learning from someone and blindly adopting their entire worldview.
If your masculinity requires constant validation from another man, perhaps it’s worth asking how independent you’ve actually become. And if your entire understanding of women comes from another man telling you what women supposedly want, perhaps speaking to an actual woman might be a useful next step…Just a thought.
The great competition between men
A considerable part of what is described as toxic masculinity has very little to do with women. It’s a competition between men.
Who earns the most? Who has the biggest house? Who has the most attractive partner? Who has the most sexual conquests? Who is the strongest, richest, most dominant and most powerful? Essentially, a never-ending dick-measuring competition. And the funny thing is that the men participating in this competition often blame women for the very expectations they impose on one another.
Toxic masculinity isn’t a clinical diagnosis, and masculinity itself isn’t toxic. We’re talking about harmful expectations such as emotional suppression, aggression, dominance and the idea that vulnerability makes a man weak. These expectations are often reinforced by other men, male role models and male peer groups. Yet somehow, women get the blame.
Apparently, we’re responsible for the competition, too. Perhaps it’s time to look at the people actually participating in it. Who told you that real men never cry? Not the women in your life…It was one or more of the influential men in your life.
When a woman stops waiting
Some manosphere influencers promise men that they can become the ideal husband: the provider, the protector, the leader and the man who gives his family everything they need. Wonderful ambitions. But what happens when the promises don’t translate into reality?
When the bills still need paying, the children still need raising, the groceries still need buying and the household still needs running? Eventually, someone has to step up. And quite often, that someone is the woman.
She starts earning more, making more decisions, taking on more responsibilities and becoming increasingly independent. Not necessarily because she wants to compete with her husband. But because somebody has to make sure the family survives.
Manosphere idiots would say she’s competing. Women will say she’s surviving.
And then comes the really interesting part. When a woman becomes financially independent, confident and capable of managing her own life, some men suddenly describe her as too masculine, too dominant or too difficult to deal with. Apparently, independence is an admirable quality until a woman shows it.
A woman who takes responsibility for herself and her children isn’t necessarily trying to replace a man. She might simply have discovered that waiting for someone else to do the job isn’t a particularly effective survival strategy. And when the relationship eventually falls apart, guess who gets blamed?
She’s too independent. She doesn’t respect men. She’s too masculine. She doesn’t know how to submit. But what about the promises that weren’t fulfilled? What about the responsibilities that weren’t shared?
A relationship cannot function on one person’s promises and the other person’s efforts.
Dear gentlemen, we are not your competition
You call women masculine when they demonstrate independence, ambition, confidence and leadership. But here’s a little secret: men and women both possess characteristics traditionally described as masculine and feminine. These aren’t two mutually exclusive biological personality packages.
Being assertive doesn’t make a woman less of a woman. Being caring doesn’t make a man less of a man. We are human beings with a wide range of characteristics, abilities and behaviours. And if you want to build a successful life, a happy family and a healthy relationship, perhaps you should stop treating women as your competition.
We don’t need to be your enemies. We don’t need to be inferior to you for you to feel superior. And we certainly don’t need to be less successful so you can feel more masculine.
Women want wealthy lifestyles, too. We want successful careers, beautiful homes, financial security and fulfilling relationships. And we’re perfectly capable of pursuing those things independently.
We dare to walk up to another woman and ask her.. how did you do that? We take inspiration from her and create the life after our own ideas and values, without 1:1 copying the other woman. We are able to support and uplift each other. To work together on our dreams and goals, even when they are completely different and don’t align with each other. That doesn’t mean we don’t appreciate men. It means we don’t need to depend on one to have a good life.
You can be a provider without having a submissive partner. You can be a leader without demanding obedience. You can be masculine without making femininity inferior. The only thing we need is trust. And perhaps most importantly, you can be a successful man without spending your time explaining why women are unsuccessful.
A final word of appreciation
Despite all my criticism, I genuinely want to acknowledge something.
I’m proud of the men who are trying. The young men who are learning to exercise, eat properly, take care of themselves, find employment, build careers and become responsible adults.
I’m proud of the men who are willing to teach other men what they’ve learned.
I’m proud of those who are trying to become better fathers, partners, colleagues and human beings.
Are all the courses scientifically accurate? Absolutely not. Are all the claims about women, biology, evolutionary psychology and relationships correct? Certainly not. Are there some rather questionable role models out there? Without a doubt. But that doesn’t mean the entire effort is worthless.
I’m a firm believer that trying and making mistakes is better than never trying at all.
Sometimes you have to encourage people, even when they’re making a complete mess of things. You know, like an elementary school teacher trying to hype up the kid who has somehow managed to get every single answer wrong. You give them a little encouragement, celebrate the effort, explain where they went wrong and hope they’ll do a little better next time.
So, gentlemen, keep exercising. Keep learning. Keep building your careers. Keep improving yourselves. Just remember that becoming a better man doesn’t require making women lesser.
And perhaps, before enrolling in another course about becoming an alpha male, consider taking a little course in mutual respect. I’m sure someone could make a list or YouTube video.
Picture by ALVIN MAHMUDOV
